Editing Diet tracking

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
−
{{Topic Infobox}}
+
=== Things that can be measured with these tools ===
−
'''Diet tracking tools''' help when engaging in the common practice of diet tracking, whether for weight-loss or in relation to health issues and chronic conditions that require particular diets. A variety of tools try to enable the tracking of food eaten, often attached to databases that enable additional data such as calories, macro/micronutrients and other things. Additionally, they can allow tracking micronutrients which are supplemented with [[Supplements]].
+
calorie intake
  
−
==Types of data recorded by diet tracking tools==
+
macronutrients; carbs proteins fats
−
What exactly is recorded by the tools can depend on the exact tool used, but recorded information includes:
 
  
−
*calorie intake
+
micronutrients; iron calcium vitamin D
−
* macronutrients: carbs, proteins, fats
 
−
*micronutrients: iron, calcium, vitamin D, etc.
 
−
*brands and manufacturers
 
−
*Degree of processing<ref>https://world.openfoodfacts.org/nova</ref>
 
−
Potentially information that is not yet noticed in any app is price of food, what is available in fridge, enjoyment, circumstances, environment surrounding eating.
 
  
−
==Projects and results from these tools==
+
brands and manufacturers
  
−
*Greg Pomerantz [https://sethroberts.net/2012/11/07/journal-of-personal-science-how-much-salt-should-i-eat/ tracked the impact of sodium/salt in his diet on blood pressure and other metrics]
+
circumstances surrounding eating including enjoyment
−
*[[Quantified Diabetes]] did some rigorous tests on the impact of different diets on blood glucose
 
−
*Winslow Strong used diet tracking in [[MyFitnessPal]] to [https://quantifiedself.com/show-and-tell/?project=155 observe how a low carbohydrate/paleo diet impacted his body]
 
  
−
==Patients and communities that need these tools==
+
=== Projects and results from these tools ===
−
Weight loss<ref>https://old.reddit.com/r/nutrition/</ref>is a very common goal. Additionally, there are communities affected by stomach and liver problems for which diet tracking is relevant<ref>https://old.reddit.com/r/ScientificNutrition/wiki/index</ref><ref>https://old.reddit.com/r/FoodNerds/top/</ref>.
 
  
−
==Diets==
+
=== Patients and communities that need these tools ===
−
There are many different diets for which tracking food intake will be relevant, e.g.
+
Weight loss is a very common goal. Communities about stomach and liver problems.
−
*Keto<ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/keto/wiki/faq</ref><ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/ketoscience/wiki/index</ref>
 
−
*Intermittent Fasting<ref>https://www.reddit.com/r/fasting/wiki/fasting_in_a_nutshell/dangers_of_dry_fasting</ref>
 
−
*Juicing<ref>https://old.reddit.com/r/Juicing/top/</ref>
 
−
* Plant Based<ref>https://old.reddit.com/r/PlantBasedDiet/top/</ref>
 
  
−
==Tips and guides to using diet tracking tools==
+
=== Technical guide to these tools ===
−
Typically most tools are somewhat self-explanatory after installation. Beyond this, there are some tips and advice on how to consistently track diet: 
+
Usually just install them and the rest is self explanatory. Buy a kitchen scale for accuracy on amounts eaten if you cook or eat at restaurants without standard food quantities. {{Tool Infobox
 +
|Category=Observe
 +
}}
  
−
* Buying a kitchen scale can be useful to accurately track the amounts eaten, in particular if you cook yourself or eat at restaurants that don't have standard food quantities. Fractions of a package too.
+
{| class="wikitable" style="margin-left: auto; margin-right: 0px;"
−
*Frequently, people engaging in diet tracking find that the manual labor of recording their diets becomes too onerous and quit after a few months. [[User:DG|DG]] suggests regularly repeating meals as this a) speeds up the speed of logging data as it will be a 'recently used meal' (e.g. as available in the tool [[Bitesnap]]) and b) also can help find patterns in the data. Wildly inaccurate measurements are still better than nothing, especially for things like eliminating a food as a problem.
+
!name
−
 
+
!<small>quantity timestamp  export</small>
−
== Table of common diet tracking tools==
+
!<small>notes</small>
−
 
+
!<small>offline</small>
−
This table is adapted from the [[Quantified Self]] forums<ref>https://forum.quantifiedself.com/t/recommended-food-tracking-apps/252/38</ref> and might in places be outdated. Empty cells are unknown information. Yellow check-marks indicate some basic functionality of this type. The different columns indicate:
+
!<small>Price &</small>
−
 
+
<small>paywall</small>
−
* '''Quantity''': Allows changing food quantities
+
!<small>search fave/recent barcode</small>
−
* '''Timestamp''': Gives a detailed timestamp on when food was eaten
+
!<small>detailnutrition serv.choiceselect customfood</small>
−
* '''Export''': Allows exporting data in the form of a file
+
!<small>water</small>
−
* '''Notes''': Entries have a free-text field to give additional information (e.g. where it was eaten, whether tasty or not…)
 
−
* '''Offline''': Does the app (mostly) work when not being online?
 
−
* '''Price''': How much does the app or a subscription to it cost?
 
−
* '''Search''': Can one search by food name?
 
−
* '''Favorite/Recent''': In the menu to add food, is there the list of foods ordered by most likely?
 
−
* '''Barcode''': Can food be searched by scanning the barcode on it?
 
−
* '''Micronutrients''': Does the app include details on micronutrients?
 
−
* '''User-added food''': Does the app include user contributions to expand their food database?
 
−
* '''Custom food''': Can you add your own food that's missing from the database?
 
−
* '''Water''': Does it allow tracking water intake
 
−
 
 
−
{| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible"
 
−
|+
 
−
A table of common diet-tracking tools.
 
−
!Tool
 
−
!Quantity
 
−
!Timestamps
 
−
!Data export
 
−
!Notes
 
−
!Offline
 
−
!Price
 
−
!Search
 
−
!Favorite/Recent
 
−
!Barcode
 
−
!Micronutrients
 
−
! User-added food
 
−
!Custom food
 
−
!Water tracking
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[Bitesnap]]
+
|bitesnap
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|F
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| w y y
−
|free
+
| y y n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| w
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[MyNetDiary]]
+
|cronometer
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y p  p
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|p
−
|Paid
+
| n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|$50 / year
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[Waistline]]
+
|myfitnesspal
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y p w
−
|{{Na}}
+
|w
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|w
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|40/y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|open source
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[Cronometer]]
+
|Waistline
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|y n y
−
|Paid
+
|y
−
|Paid
+
|y
−
|Paid
+
|O
−
|{{Na}}
+
|y ? n
 +
|w w y
 
|
 
|
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[MyFitnessPal]]
+
|looseit
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|n
−
|Paid
+
|y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| y y y
−
|$40 / year
+
| w n ?
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| p
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[LooseIt]]
+
|SparklePeople
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n p
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|[[SparklePeople]]
+
|fooducate
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n p
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|Paid
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Fooducate
+
|fatsecret
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|Paid
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| y y w
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| w
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|FatSecret
+
|eathismuch
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|?
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| w y w
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| w y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|EatThisMuch
+
|mynetdairy
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| y y y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| w
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Glucose Buddy
+
|glucosebuddy
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| ? y n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|n
−
|{{Na}}
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| w y y
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| y y n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|My Diet Diary
+
|my diet diary
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|w
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
| w y n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|{{Na}}
+
| y
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
 
|MyPlate
 
|MyPlate
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|w
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| w n y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| ?
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|Smart Plate
+
|smartplate
−
|{{Na}}
+
| n n ?
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
 
 
|
 
|
−
|
+
| y y y
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n n ?
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| ?
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
−
|{{MaybeCheck}}
 
 
|-
 
|-
−
|OpenFoodFacts
+
| openfoodfacts
−
|{{Na}}
+
| n n y
−
|{{Na}}
+
|n
−
|{{Ya}}
+
|  
−
|{{Na}}
+
|O
−
|
+
| y y y
−
|open source
+
| y y y most detailed Database
−
|{{Ya}}
+
| n
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|-
 
−
|YAZIO
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|free
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|-
 
−
|hranoprovod-cli
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|open source
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Na}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
−
|{{Ya}}
 
 
|}
 
|}
  
−
=== Databases ===
+
* '''quantity''' = allows changing quantity
−
https://www.foodrepo.org/ Community-driven for barcoded food products.
+
* '''timestamp''' = includes detailed to the minute timestamps
−
 
+
* '''export''' = allows exporting to file like CSV. Likely missed transfer through 3rd party aggregation.
−
https://world.openfoodfacts.org/ Open source collaborative originally from France. Derived scores for amount of processing and nutritional quality.
+
* Ordered by these three features because they are critical to QS.  
−
 
+
*'''notes''' = manually entered text field that allows writing down custom information and features. For example how tasty the food was, or where it was bought, or what brand of generic food was purchased.
−
https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/ US government.
+
* '''offline''' = does not require connection to internet for some or almost all of their features to work.
−
 
+
* '''Price''' = Apps can require continuous payment (such as MFP requiring 40$ per year), one time upfront cost,  free and one is even open source. The amount of features walled off from non paying users also varies.
−
===References===
+
** '''O''' = Open Source
−
<references />
+
** '''F''' = Free
−
 
+
** '''/y''' = per year.
 +
* '''search''' = search by name
 +
* '''fave/recent''' = can repeat or rank in search based on popular/recent
 +
* '''barcode''' = can find food by scanning barcode (requires online connectivity)
 +
* '''detailnutrition''' = Detail of nutrition tracked varies between apps as some track just macronutrients while others go into greater detail.
 +
* '''serv.choiceselect''' = Some apps use user contributions to populate their database of foods while others use formal databases like USDA.
 +
* '''customfood''' = Some apps do not allow entering custom foods!
  
 +
==== What the letters mean. ====
 +
*'''y''' = Yes, has feature.
 +
*'''n''' = does not. ’ ’ is same as '''n'''
 +
*'''p''' = feature requires membership
 +
*'''w''' = the feature exists but is not as good as a '''y'''
 +
*'''?''' = I do not know.
  
−
[[Category:Topics]]
+
Source: https://forum.quantifiedself.com/t/recommended-food-tracking-apps/252/38 (May 2019)

Please note that all contributions to Personal Science Wiki are considered to be released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported (see PersonalScienceWiki:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page:

Retrieved from "https://wiki.openhumans.org/wiki/Diet_tracking"