Difference between revisions of "How do controls on antigen COVID tests work?"
m |
m (remove wrong formatting of section headers) |
||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
[[File:Covid-test-buffer-only.jpg|alt=A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with buffer liquid. The control line appears.|thumb|A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with buffer liquid. The control line appears.]] | [[File:Covid-test-buffer-only.jpg|alt=A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with buffer liquid. The control line appears.|thumb|A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with buffer liquid. The control line appears.]] | ||
| − | === | + | === Reasoning === |
If the control on the rapid COVID test were to identify that the user correctly swabbed their nose, it should detect some molecules that are universally present in the human nose. Conversely, in this case the control line should not appear if the test is ''only'' loaded with the buffer liquid that is part of the test kit without having performed any swabbing. | If the control on the rapid COVID test were to identify that the user correctly swabbed their nose, it should detect some molecules that are universally present in the human nose. Conversely, in this case the control line should not appear if the test is ''only'' loaded with the buffer liquid that is part of the test kit without having performed any swabbing. | ||
| − | === | + | === Test === |
To test this, we loaded a antigen COVID test using only the buffer liquid without performing any swabbing. | To test this, we loaded a antigen COVID test using only the buffer liquid without performing any swabbing. | ||
| − | === | + | ===Result=== |
Within a few seconds after loading the test the ''control'' line appeared. The control line that appears on a rapid COVID test '''does not''' indicate that one has correctly taken a sample, it '''only indicates that one loaded the test correctly.''' | Within a few seconds after loading the test the ''control'' line appeared. The control line that appears on a rapid COVID test '''does not''' indicate that one has correctly taken a sample, it '''only indicates that one loaded the test correctly.''' | ||
== Experiment 2: Loading the test only with ''Coke Zero'' == | == Experiment 2: Loading the test only with ''Coke Zero'' == | ||
| − | === | + | === Reasoning === |
[[File:Covid-coke-zero.png|alt=A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with Coke Zero. Initially only the control line appears, but after a while the test line appears too.|thumb|A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with ''Coke Zero''. Initially only the ''control'' line appears, but after a while the ''test'' line appears too.]] | [[File:Covid-coke-zero.png|alt=A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with Coke Zero. Initially only the control line appears, but after a while the test line appears too.|thumb|A rapid, antigen COVID test that was loaded only with ''Coke Zero''. Initially only the ''control'' line appears, but after a while the ''test'' line appears too.]] | ||
We also had heard that kids are using sodas such as ''Coca Cola'' to turn their rapid COVID tests positive to not have to go to school. In good research fashion we decided to skip the literature research (which would have shown us that this is indeed the case<ref name=":0">https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210705-how-children-are-spoofing-covid-19-tests-with-soft-drinks</ref>) and immediately proceeded to testing whether this works. | We also had heard that kids are using sodas such as ''Coca Cola'' to turn their rapid COVID tests positive to not have to go to school. In good research fashion we decided to skip the literature research (which would have shown us that this is indeed the case<ref name=":0">https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20210705-how-children-are-spoofing-covid-19-tests-with-soft-drinks</ref>) and immediately proceeded to testing whether this works. | ||
| − | === | + | === Test === |
We loaded an antigen test only using a few drops of ''Coke Zero'' and observed which of the control & test lines would appear over time. | We loaded an antigen test only using a few drops of ''Coke Zero'' and observed which of the control & test lines would appear over time. | ||
Revision as of 08:23, 4 May 2022
Project Infobox 
| |
|---|---|
| Self researcher(s) | Paulina Ejsmont, Maira Goytia, Tim Dobbs, Yann Huon de Kermadec, User:Gedankenstuecke |
| Related tools | COVID tests |
| Related topics | |
Builds on project(s) |
|
| Has inspired | Projects (0) |
There are a large number of different rapid COVID tests, both for professionals but also for self-testing at home. Beyond the actual test indicator (shown by the T line on the test), these tests also contain a control indicator (shown by the C line on the test) that should appear regardless of whether COVID was detected or not.
During the self-research chat on April 28 the question of how these controls work came up. Do they indicate that the person taking the test did correctly swab their nose to take a sample? Or do they only indicate that the test itself was correctly loaded and that liquid is present?
After discussing this question over lunch at work, we decided to solve this question by doing two small experiments using regular COVID tests for home-use and loaded these in different ways to observe what would happen.
Experiment #1: Loading the test with only the provided buffer liquid
Reasoning
If the control on the rapid COVID test were to identify that the user correctly swabbed their nose, it should detect some molecules that are universally present in the human nose. Conversely, in this case the control line should not appear if the test is only loaded with the buffer liquid that is part of the test kit without having performed any swabbing.
Test
To test this, we loaded a antigen COVID test using only the buffer liquid without performing any swabbing.
Result
Within a few seconds after loading the test the control line appeared. The control line that appears on a rapid COVID test does not indicate that one has correctly taken a sample, it only indicates that one loaded the test correctly.
Experiment 2: Loading the test only with Coke Zero
Reasoning
We also had heard that kids are using sodas such as Coca Cola to turn their rapid COVID tests positive to not have to go to school. In good research fashion we decided to skip the literature research (which would have shown us that this is indeed the case[1]) and immediately proceeded to testing whether this works.
Test
We loaded an antigen test only using a few drops of Coke Zero and observed which of the control & test lines would appear over time.
Result
As for the first experiment, the control line appeared within a few seconds. When revisiting the test strip after 30 minutes, the test line also appeared, giving the wrong indication of a positive test. Apparently, this is due to the acidity of the soda, which leads to the false-positive result[1]. In contrast, the pH of the buffer solution would be at around 8.
References
Linked content on this wiki
(The content in the table below is automatically created. See Template:Project Queries for details. If newly linked pages do not appear here, click on "More" and "Refresh".)
| Project that build on this project |
|---|
| We talked about this project in the following meetings |
|---|
| 2022-05-05 Self-Research Chat |